SoundCloud Cuts 41% Of Its Workforce – What Went Wrong?

SoundCloud is downsizing significantly. Where did it go wrong, and what does this say about the state of streaming in 2017?  

It’s tough times at SoundCloud as the company is set to fire 173 of its 420 employees in order “to put the company on our path to profitability and in control of SoundCloud’s independent future”, as an official statement suggests.

While we’re constantly being told that music streaming is the way we all have to listen these days, an uncomfortable fact is that very few companies actually make money out of it. Giants like Apple and Google / Alphabet (with Apple Music and YouTube respectively) run their streaming services more or less as “loss leaders”, a way to get you to use their other services or buy products that do make handsome profits. And while smaller companies may be valued in the hundreds of millions, like so much in the dotcom world, much of that value is based on a combination of venture capital funding and perceived profitability in the future.

The idea behind SoundCloud is a good one – an audio-focused platform for hosting and sharing that isn’t YouTube with its giant corporate associations. But the company has struggled to monetise its users, who are averse to being served ads before they can hear content. There’s often not a compelling reason for someone to pay for a pro plan. Although the amount is fairly modest, YouTube is free and there are other competitors for your $8 a month that you might go for instead. The delineation between free and paid tiers seems slight – some expanded stats, tracking and more upload time. Businesses or professional bands might find these useful, but most regular users won’t.  

The upgrade options

The upgrade options

Add to this the fact that the service hasn’t really appeared to change or improve all that much over its lifetime, unlike other web services that often get overhauled every few years. SoundCloud can still be buggy on mobile, which is a critical market for any tech company. And perhaps controversially, can anyone explain how they need 420 employees? It feels like they might have made the classic dotcom mistake of prioritising rapid physical growth over really sorting out their business model. Like they went after “big company” status but with a product and a model that was really better suited to a much smaller company. Do they need offices in Berlin, New York, London, San Francisco, Los Angeles and Sydney?

Some blame the royalties that streaming companies pay for the content they stream for the financial difficulties, but that’s not an argument that will cut much ice with the vast majority of artists who are getting cents for hundreds or even thousands of plays.

For all the talk of people wanting everything for free, there’s a lot of evidence that people will pay for content they actually want – but it has to be just that.

Have you ever paid for one of SoundCloud’s pro plans and if so, did you feel it was worth it? Would you miss it if it was gone? Let us know in the comments. 

 Learn music business essentials from copyright to licensing to royalties in these popular courses: https://ask.audio/academy?nleloc=topic/musicbusiness

 

Hollin Jones was classically trained as a piano player but found the lure of blues and jazz too much to resist. Graduating from bands to composition then production, he relishes the chance to play anything with keys. A sometime lecturer in videographics, music production and photography post production, Hollin has been a freelance w... Read More

Discussion

Thebanks
I had a pro account a few years back when I was writing a lot of songs.
Not writing songs so much these days as it wasn't paying the bills and it takes a lot of time.
I really liked SoundCloud as platform for getting my songs "out there" and for getting feedback from peers.
Hope they can turn it round.
Natocore
I pay for a pro account because I have over 700 sounds on there. I put up all my review mixes so I can walk around and review my songs and get feed back from fans before final mixes go for sale on bandcamp. I love being able to share links from soundcloud. I have been writing 1 to 3 songs a week since 2013. Soundcloud is a daily part of my life and the 90 bucks a year for unlimited is fair for me to showcase my content. I just wish it was easier to search my own catalogue or randomise the listening of an artist's catalogue instead of just chronological.

Want to join the discussion?

Create an account or login to get started!